Vibrating fork level sensor comparison
By Dhananjay Palshikar on April 18, 2019
Tuning forks are used in various fields from acoustics to medical diagnostics. In their miniature form tuning forks made of Quartz crystal are used in watches for measuring time.
40 years in the Industry
Tuning forks have been commonly used in the industry since the 1970s. They were introduced as alternatives to Rotating Paddle Level Switches.
Vibrtaing Fork Level Sensors have stood the test of time and continue to dominate the point level switch market.
Sapcon Instruments has been manufacturing vibrating fork level sensors since its inception in the year 1983. Since then, Vibrating fork has evolved into a much more compact and faster level switch. The success and popularity of these level sensors can largely be attributed to:
- Calibration Free Operation
- Relatively Long Operational Life Expectancy
How do the tuning fork tines vibrate?
Pressure applied by the piezoelectric stack on the diaphram causes it to shear, which in turn drives the tines apart from each other. See the figure below for a simulation of the process. When the pressure is removed the tines return to their orginal position.
The application of force when applied at the fork's Natural Frequency makes the it oscillate at its maximum amplitude for a given power.
How does the level sensor detect application media?
A tuning fork vibrating continuosly at its natural frequency is monitored for two specific paraments:
- Frequency of operation
- Amplitude of Vibration
Detecting Solid application media
As the material level increases and comes in contact with the Vibrating Fork tines, the amplitude of osciallation of tuning fork dampens. When the amplitude goes below a set threshold, the onboard electronics causes a change to the outputs(Relays/ PNP).
Detecting Liquid application media
The natural frequency of oscillation for the tuning fork decreases as it comes in contact with the liquid application media. The threshold frequency is set to match the natural frequency of tuning fork under water as shown here:
Selecting the right tuning forkThe natural frequency of tuning fork increases with increase in the length of tines. in two rows, one for solid and another for liquid
A comparison of the tuning forks vis-a-vis their performance and end-use has been shown below for a better understanding.
|Tines Length||220 mm||155 mm||Vital- 100 mm||Elixir -100 mm||44 mm|
|Natural Frequency in air (Hz) approx.||80||150||300||300||1600|
|Response time(fastest)||3 sec||2 sec||0.5 sec||1 sec||1 sec|
|Typical Application||General Purpose||General Purpose||Fast Packaging Machines and compact silos||non-foaming liquids or free flowing solids||Hygienic Design.all freely flowing liquids,liquids with foam, compact silos|
On site settings and configuration
A simple slide switch interface makes on-site adjustments possible.
|Performance Parameter||Effect||Application||Side Effect|
|Sensitivity||Ampltitude of vibration and threshold ampltiude used for switching.||Detecting Low Density Media||Switching Position and buildup immunity|
|Time Delay||Additional Time Delays for process automation||Preventing malfunction by ignoring turbulence in silos.||none|
Comparison of Vibrating Fork Level Sensors vs other point Level Switches
|Product Principle||Vibrating Fork||Capacitance||RF-Admittance||Rotating Paddle||Remarks|
|Type of Application Media||Free flowing solids and liquids||Free flowing solids and liquids||Solids, Semi-solids with tendancy to buildup||Granular Solids||RF-Admittance covers most materials|
|Calibration Free||✔||✖||✖||✔||No calibration requirement leads to quick installation and commissioning|
|Dependance on Physical Property||
Freely flowing solids
|Dielectric Constant||Density > 0.5 g/cm3||Dielectric constant variantion is difficult to track, variation in density can be measured easily. Performance of Vibrating Fork and Rotation Paddle is more predictable for a given application.|
|Budget||₹||₹||₹₹₹||₹₹||Vibrating Forks are generally priced the lowest|
|Expected Life(depends on application parameters and site conditions)||5-10 years||5-15 years||5-15 years||2-3 years||Application parameters that affect useful life(all parameters do not affect each instrument):